How to Register Recycling Business in Pakistan?

Essential Requirements for Recycling Business Registration Process

The registration of a recycling business in Pakistan involves several essential requirements:

1. Business Plan: Develop a comprehensive business plan outlining your recycling operations, target market, and financial projections.
2. Company Name: Choose a unique name for your recycling business and get it approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP).
3. Business Structure: Decide on the appropriate business structure (e.g., sole proprietorship, partnership, or limited company).
4. Capital Investment: Secure the necessary capital for initial setup and operations.
5. Location: Identify a suitable location for your recycling facility that complies with zoning regulations.
6. Environmental Compliance: Ensure adherence to environmental regulations and obtain necessary permits.
7. Tax Registration: Register for tax purposes with the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR).
8. Labor Compliance: Comply with labor laws and employee safety regulations.
9. Waste Management Licenses: Obtain required waste handling and management licenses.
10. Professional Services: Engage legal and accounting professionals to assist with the registration process.

Legal Framework Governing Recycling Companies in Pakistan

The legal framework for recycling companies in Pakistan encompasses various laws and regulations:

1. Companies Act, 2017: This act governs the incorporation and regulation of companies in Pakistan.
2. Pakistan Environmental Protection Act, 1997: This legislation provides the framework for environmental protection and waste management.
3. Factories Act, 1934: This act regulates working conditions and safety measures in industrial establishments.
4. Provincial Environmental Protection Acts: Each province has its own environmental protection laws that recycling businesses must comply with.
5. Income Tax Ordinance, 2001: This ordinance outlines the tax obligations for businesses operating in Pakistan.
6. Sales Tax Act, 1990: This act governs the imposition and collection of sales tax on goods and services.
7. Labor Laws: Various labor laws, including the Industrial Relations Act, 2012, and the Minimum Wages Ordinance, 1961, regulate employment practices.
8. Hazardous Substances Rules, 2003: These rules regulate the handling, storage, and disposal of hazardous materials.
9. Provincial Solid Waste Management Laws: Each province has specific regulations for solid waste management that recycling businesses must follow.
10. Import and Export Regulations: For businesses involved in importing or exporting recycled materials, compliance with relevant trade regulations is necessary.

Documentation Requirements for Recycling Business Setup Process

The documentation required for setting up a recycling business in Pakistan includes:

1. Memorandum and Articles of Association (for limited companies)
2. Form-1 (Application for Incorporation)
3. Form-21 (Declaration of Compliance)
4. Form-29 (Particulars of Directors)
5. National Identity Cards (NICs) of all directors and shareholders
6. Proof of registered office address
7. Bank account opening documents
8. Tax registration forms (NTN application)
9. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) report
10. No Objection Certificate (NOC) from relevant environmental authorities
11. Waste management plan
12. Safety and health policy documents
13. Employee contracts and employment records
14. Zoning approval from local authorities
15. Equipment purchase or lease agreements
16. Insurance policies (property, liability, workers’ compensation)
17. Professional licenses or certifications (if applicable)
18. Partnership deed (for partnerships)
19. Business plan and financial projections
20. Utility connection applications and approvals

Environmental Permits and Compliance Standards Implementation

Implementing environmental permits and compliance standards for a recycling business in Pakistan involves:

1. Conduct an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the proposed recycling facility.
2. Submit the EIA report to the relevant provincial Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) for approval.
3. Obtain an Initial Environmental Examination (IEE) approval if required by the provincial EPA.
4. Apply for and obtain an Environmental Protection Order (EPO) from the provincial EPA.
5. Implement waste management practices in accordance with the National Environmental Quality Standards (NEQS).
6. Install pollution control equipment as required by environmental regulations.
7. Develop and implement a comprehensive waste management plan.
8. Establish a system for regular environmental monitoring and reporting.
9. Train employees on environmental compliance and best practices.
10. Obtain necessary permits for air emissions, water discharge, and solid waste disposal.
11. Implement a hazardous waste management system if dealing with hazardous materials.
12. Conduct regular environmental audits to ensure ongoing compliance.
13. Maintain records of environmental compliance and submit periodic reports to relevant authorities.
14. Engage with local communities to address any environmental concerns.
15. Stay updated on changes in environmental regulations and adjust operations accordingly.

Government Authorities Involved in Registration Applications

Several government authorities are involved in the registration process for recycling businesses in Pakistan:

1. Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP): Responsible for company registration and incorporation.
2. Federal Board of Revenue (FBR): Handles tax registration and compliance matters.
3. Provincial Environmental Protection Agencies (EPAs): Oversee environmental compliance and issue necessary permits.
4. Local Government Authorities: Provide zoning approvals and local business licenses.
5. Pakistan Standards and Quality Control Authority (PSQCA): Sets standards for recycling equipment and processes.
6. Ministry of Climate Change: Provides policy guidelines for waste management and recycling.
7. Provincial Labor Departments: Oversee compliance with labor laws and workplace safety regulations.
8. Employees Old-Age Benefits Institution (EOBI): Manages employee pension and social security registrations.
9. Provincial Solid Waste Management Boards: Regulate solid waste management activities.
10. Pakistan Customs: Involved in the import and export of recycled materials.
11. State Bank of Pakistan: Regulates foreign investment in recycling businesses.
12. Provincial Industries Departments: Provide support and incentives for industrial development.
13. Chamber of Commerce and Industry: Offers business support and networking opportunities.
14. Pakistan Environmental Protection Agency: Provides overall environmental policy guidance.
15. Ministry of Industries and Production: Supports industrial development and policy formulation.

Financial Requirements for Recycling Company Registration Process

The financial requirements for registering a recycling company in Pakistan include:

1. Minimum Paid-up Capital: For a private limited company, the minimum paid-up capital is PKR 100,000.
2. Registration Fees: Pay the required registration fees to SECP, which vary based on the company’s authorized capital.
3. Bank Account: Open a corporate bank account with the minimum required deposit.
4. Tax Registration Fees: Pay the necessary fees for obtaining a National Tax Number (NTN) and Sales Tax Registration.
5. Environmental Permit Fees: Allocate funds for environmental impact assessment and permit application fees.
6. Legal and Professional Fees: Budget for legal and accounting services during the registration process.
7. Office Space: Secure funds for renting or purchasing office space and recycling facility.
8. Equipment and Machinery: Allocate capital for purchasing or leasing recycling equipment.
9. Insurance Premiums: Set aside funds for various insurance policies required for the business.
10. Working Capital: Ensure sufficient working capital for initial operations and employee salaries.
11. Utility Deposits: Prepare funds for utility connection deposits and initial bills.
12. Marketing and Branding: Allocate budget for initial marketing and branding efforts.
13. Employee Training: Set aside funds for employee training programs on recycling operations and safety.
14. Compliance Costs: Budget for ongoing compliance costs, including environmental monitoring and reporting.
15. Contingency Fund: Maintain a contingency fund for unforeseen expenses during the registration process.

Business Structure Selection for Recycling Operations

Selecting the appropriate business structure for recycling operations in Pakistan involves considering the following options:

1. Sole Proprietorship:
   • Simple structure with full control by the owner
   • Unlimited personal liability
   • Suitable for small-scale recycling operations
2. Partnership:
   • Shared ownership and management
   • Partners have unlimited liability
   • Allows pooling of resources and expertise
3. Limited Liability Partnership (LLP):
   • Combines features of partnership and limited liability company
   • Partners have limited liability
   • Suitable for professional services related to recycling
4. Private Limited Company:
   • Separate legal entity from owners
   • Limited liability for shareholders
   • More complex registration process but offers better protection
5. Public Limited Company:
   • Can raise capital from the public through share offerings
   • Suitable for large-scale recycling operations
   • Subject to more stringent regulatory requirements
6. Non-Profit Organization:
   • For recycling initiatives with social or environmental goals
   • Tax-exempt status available for qualifying organizations
   • Limited to non-profit activities
7. Cooperative Society:
   • Owned and operated by members for mutual benefit
   • Suitable for community-based recycling initiatives
   • Governed by specific cooperative laws
8. Joint Venture:
   • Collaboration between two or more entities
   • Allows sharing of resources and risks
   • Suitable for large-scale or specialized recycling projects
9. Franchise:
   • Operate under an established recycling brand
   • Benefit from existing systems and brand recognition
   • Subject to franchise agreement terms
10. Branch Office:
    • For foreign companies establishing a presence in Pakistan
    • Limited to certain activities as per regulations
    • Requires approval from the Board of Investment

Read More:

• E-commerce Registration Process in Pakistan
• IT Park Registration Process in Pakistan
• Broadcasting License Process in Pakistan

Tax Registration and Compliance Requirements Overview

Tax registration and compliance requirements for recycling businesses in Pakistan include:

1. National Tax Number (NTN):
   • Apply for NTN with the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR)
   • Required for all businesses operating in Pakistan
2. Sales Tax Registration:
   • Register for sales tax if annual turnover exceeds PKR 5 million
   • Collect and remit sales tax on taxable supplies
3. Income Tax:
   • File annual income tax returns
   • Pay advance tax on a quarterly basis
4. Withholding Tax:
   • Deduct and remit withholding tax on various transactions
   • File monthly withholding tax statements
5. Provincial Sales Tax:
   • Register with provincial revenue authorities if providing services
   • Collect and remit provincial sales tax where applicable
6. Customs Duty:
   • Pay applicable customs duties on imported recycling equipment
   • Comply with import regulations for recycled materials
7. Property Tax:
   • Pay annual property tax on owned business premises
   • Rates vary by location and property value
8. Professional Tax:
   • Register and pay professional tax to provincial authorities
   • Rates vary by province and business category
9. Social Security Contributions:
   • Register with EOBI and provincial social security institutions
   • Make regular contributions for employee benefits
10. Workers Welfare Fund:
    • Contribute to the Workers Welfare Fund as per regulations
    • Applicable to companies with annual income exceeding PKR 500,000
11. Tax Audits:
    • Maintain proper financial records for potential tax audits
    • Cooperate with tax authorities during audit processes
12. E-Filing:
    • Use FBR’s online portal for tax return filing and payments
    • Ensure timely submission of all required tax documents
13. Tax Exemptions:
    • Apply for available tax exemptions or incentives for recycling businesses
    • Comply with conditions attached to any granted exemptions
14. Double Taxation Treaties:
    • Understand and apply relevant double taxation treaties if engaged in international operations
15. Tax Planning:
    • Engage in legal tax planning to optimize tax liabilities
    • Seek professional advice for complex tax matters

Location and Zoning Requirements for Recycling Business

Location and zoning requirements for establishing a recycling business in Pakistan include:

1. Industrial Zoning:
   • Ensure the chosen location is zoned for industrial or recycling activities
   • Obtain zoning verification from local authorities
2. Environmental Considerations:
   • Select a site that minimizes environmental impact on surrounding areas
   • Comply with buffer zone requirements from residential areas
3. Accessibility:
   • Choose a location with good road access for transportation of materials
   • Consider proximity to suppliers and customers
4. Utility Availability:
   • Verify the availability of necessary utilities (electricity, water, gas)
   • Ensure adequate power supply for recycling equipment
5. Land Use Regulations:
   • Adhere to local land use regulations and development plans
   • Obtain necessary land use permits or approvals
6. Size and Expansion Potential:
   • Select a site with sufficient space for current operations and future expansion
   • Consider long-term growth plans when choosing the location
7. Flood Risk Assessment:
   • Evaluate the site’s susceptibility to flooding or other natural disasters
   • Implement necessary mitigation measures if required
8. Noise and Pollution Control:
   • Ensure compliance with local noise and pollution control regulations
   • Implement necessary measures to minimize disturbance to neighboring areas
9. Traffic Impact:
   • Assess the impact of increased traffic on local roads
   • Obtain traffic management approvals if required
10. Community Acceptance:
    • Consider community attitudes towards recycling facilities in the area
    • Engage with local stakeholders to address concerns
11. Special Economic Zones:
    • Explore opportunities in Special Economic Zones with favorable conditions for recycling businesses
12. Proximity to Waste Sources:
    • Consider proximity to major waste generation sources for efficient collection
13. Storage Requirements:
    • Ensure adequate space for safe storage of recyclable materials and processed products
14. Fire Safety:
    • Comply with fire safety regulations and ensure adequate fire prevention measures
15. Local Development Plans:
    • Align the location choice with local and regional development plans

Equipment and Infrastructure Standards for Registration

Equipment and infrastructure standards for registering a recycling business in Pakistan include:

1. Sorting Equipment:
   • Install efficient sorting systems for different types of recyclable materials
   • Ensure compliance with industry standards for sorting accuracy
2. Processing Machinery:
   • Acquire processing equipment suitable for the types of materials being recycled
   • Meet safety and efficiency standards for processing machinery
3. Storage Facilities:
   • Provide adequate storage areas for incoming materials and processed products
   • Implement proper storage systems to prevent contamination and ensure safety
4. Weighing Systems:
   • Install accurate weighing equipment for incoming and outgoing materials
   • Calibrate weighing systems regularly to maintain accuracy
5. Safety Equipment:
   • Provide necessary personal protective equipment (PPE) for workers
   • Install fire safety equipment and emergency response systems
6. Pollution Control Systems:
   • Implement air filtration and water treatment systems as required
   • Meet emission and effluent standards set by environmental authorities
7. Transportation Equipment:
   • Acquire suitable vehicles for collection and transportation of recyclable materials
   • Ensure vehicles meet safety and environmental standards
8. Quality Control Equipment:
   • Install equipment for testing and quality assurance of recycled products
   • Meet industry standards for product quality and consistency
9. Energy Efficiency:
   • Use energy-efficient equipment and processes to minimize environmental impact
   • Implement energy management systems to optimize power consumption
10. Waste Water Treatment:
    • Install waste water treatment facilities if required for the recycling process
    • Comply with water discharge standards set by environmental authorities
11. Material Handling Equipment:
    • Provide appropriate forklifts, conveyors, and other material handling equipment
    • Ensure equipment meets safety standards for industrial use
12. IT Infrastructure:
    • Implement inventory management and tracking systems
    • Install necessary computer systems and software for business operations
13. Maintenance Facilities:
    • Set up maintenance areas for equipment repair and upkeep
    • Stock essential spare parts and tools for regular maintenance
14. Laboratory Facilities:
    • Establish on-site testing laboratories if required for quality control
    • Equip laboratories with necessary analytical instruments
15. Office Infrastructure:
    • Set up administrative offices with necessary communication systems
    • Provide adequate facilities for staff, including restrooms and break areas

Employee Safety and Labor Law Compliance Process

The process for ensuring employee safety and labor law compliance in a recycling business in Pakistan involves:

1. Develop a comprehensive workplace safety policy in line with the Factories Act, 1934.
2. Conduct regular safety training sessions for all employees, covering:
   • Proper use of personal protective equipment (PPE)
   • Safe operation of machinery and equipment
   • Emergency procedures and evacuation plans
3. Provide appropriate PPE to all workers, including:
   • Safety helmets, gloves, and steel-toed boots
   • Eye and ear protection where necessary
   • Respiratory protection for dusty environments
4. Implement a system for regular safety inspections and hazard assessments.
5. Establish an occupational health and safety committee as required by law.
6. Maintain an accident and incident reporting system, including investigation procedures.
7. Comply with working hours regulations as per the Factories Act, 1934:
   • Maximum 48 hours per week for adult workers
   • Provide one day off per week
   • Limit overtime work and provide appropriate compensation
8. Implement proper ventilation and lighting systems in the recycling facility.
9. Install fire safety equipment and conduct regular fire drills.
10. Register with the Employees Old-Age Benefits Institution (EOBI) and make regular contributions.
11. Provide health insurance coverage as required by provincial labor laws.
12. Comply with minimum wage regulations set by provincial governments.
13. Maintain proper employment records, including contracts and attendance registers.
14. Implement a grievance redressal mechanism for employees.
15. Conduct regular health check-ups for workers exposed to hazardous materials.

Waste Management Licensing and Permit Requirements

Waste management licensing and permit requirements for recycling businesses in Pakistan include:

1. Environmental Protection Order (EPO):
   • Obtain an EPO from the provincial Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)
   • Submit an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) or Initial Environmental Examination (IEE)
2. Hazardous Substance License:
   • Apply for a license to handle hazardous substances if applicable
   • Comply with the Hazardous Substances Rules, 2003
3. Solid Waste Management License:
   • Obtain a license from the provincial Solid Waste Management Board
   • Submit a comprehensive waste management plan
4. Air Emission Permit:
   • Apply for an air emission permit if the recycling process involves air pollutants
   • Comply with National Environmental Quality Standards (NEQS) for air emissions
5. Wastewater Discharge Permit:
   • Obtain a permit for wastewater discharge if applicable
   • Install wastewater treatment facilities as required
6. Transportation Permit:
   • Acquire permits for vehicles used in waste collection and transportation
   • Comply with regulations for safe transportation of recyclable materials
7. Storage Permit:
   • Obtain permits for storing recyclable materials and processed products
   • Implement proper storage practices as per regulatory requirements
8. Recycling Process Approval:
   • Get approval for the recycling processes and technologies used
   • Demonstrate compliance with environmental and safety standards
9. Workers Health and Safety Permit:
   • Obtain necessary permits related to worker health and safety
   • Implement required safety measures and training programs
10. Import/Export Licenses:
    • Acquire licenses for importing or exporting recyclable materials or equipment
    • Comply with customs regulations and international trade agreements
11. Local Government Permits:
    • Obtain any additional permits required by local municipal authorities
    • Comply with local waste management and recycling regulations
12. Renewal and Reporting:
    • Maintain a system for timely renewal of all licenses and permits
    • Submit regular reports to relevant authorities as required
13. Compliance Audits:
    • Prepare for and cooperate with compliance audits by regulatory bodies
    • Maintain proper records of all licensing and permit-related activities
14. Community Engagement:
    • Engage with local communities as part of the licensing process
    • Address community concerns related to recycling operations
15. Professional Certifications:
    • Ensure key personnel have necessary professional certifications
    • Comply with any industry-specific certification requirements

Professional Services Required for Registration Process

The professional services required for the registration process of a recycling business in Pakistan include:

1. Legal Counsel:
   • Assist with company incorporation and registration
   • Review and prepare legal documents
   • Provide guidance on regulatory compliance
2. Chartered Accountant:
   • Prepare financial statements and projections
   • Assist with tax registration and compliance
   • Provide financial advisory services
3. Environmental Consultant:
   • Conduct Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA)
   • Assist with environmental permit applications
   • Advise on environmental compliance measures
4. Company Secretary:
   • Handle corporate governance matters
   • Manage regulatory filings and record-keeping
   • Ensure compliance with company law requirements
5. Tax Consultant:
   • Advise on tax planning and optimization
   • Assist with tax registrations and filings
   • Provide guidance on tax incentives for recycling businesses
6. Intellectual Property Lawyer:
   • Register trademarks and patents if applicable
   • Protect intellectual property rights
7. Human Resources Consultant:
   • Assist with labor law compliance
   • Develop HR policies and procedures
   • Advise on employee benefits and compensation
8. Insurance Broker:
   • Recommend appropriate insurance coverage
   • Assist with insurance policy procurement
9. Waste Management Specialist:
   • Advise on waste management practices
   • Assist with waste management permit applications
10. Occupational Health and Safety Consultant:
    • Develop safety policies and procedures
    • Conduct safety audits and risk assessments
11. Business Consultant:
    • Assist with business plan development
    • Provide market analysis and strategic advice
12. Architect or Civil Engineer:
    • Design recycling facility layout
    • Assist with building permit applications
13. Equipment Supplier:
    • Provide technical specifications for recycling equipment
    • Assist with equipment installation and commissioning
14. Public Relations Consultant:
    • Manage community relations
    • Develop communication strategies for stakeholders
15. Banking Relationship Manager:
    • Assist with corporate account opening
    • Provide guidance on financial services and products

Investment Guidelines for Recycling Business Setup

Investment guidelines for setting up a recycling business in Pakistan include:

1. Market Research:
   • Conduct thorough market analysis to identify recycling opportunities
   • Assess demand for recycled materials in local and international markets
2. Business Plan Development:
   • Create a comprehensive business plan outlining operations, financials, and growth strategy
   • Include detailed cost projections and revenue forecasts
3. Capital Requirements:
   • Determine initial capital needs for equipment, facilities, and working capital
   • Consider both equity and debt financing options
4. Location Selection:
   • Choose a strategic location considering factors like accessibility and zoning regulations
   • Evaluate infrastructure and utility availability at potential sites
5. Technology Assessment:
   • Research and select appropriate recycling technologies
   • Consider scalability and future technological advancements
6. Regulatory Compliance:
   • Allocate funds for obtaining necessary licenses and permits
   • Budget for ongoing compliance costs
7. Human Resources:
   • Plan for recruitment and training of skilled workforce
   • Consider labor costs and availability in the chosen location
8. Supply Chain Management:
   • Develop strategies for sourcing recyclable materials
   • Establish relationships with suppliers and waste generators
9. Marketing and Sales:
   • Allocate budget for marketing and brand development
   • Plan for sales and distribution channels for recycled products
10. Risk Assessment:
    • Identify potential risks and develop mitigation strategies
    • Consider insurance coverage for various business risks
11. Environmental Impact:
    • Invest in environmentally friendly processes and equipment
    • Allocate funds for environmental compliance and monitoring
12. Government Incentives:
    • Explore available government incentives for recycling businesses
    • Factor in potential tax benefits in financial projections
13. Phased Investment:
    • Consider a phased investment approach to manage risks
    • Plan for expansion based on initial performance and market response
14. Technology Transfer:
    • Explore partnerships or licensing agreements for advanced recycling technologies
    • Allocate funds for technology acquisition and adaptation
15. Contingency Planning:
    • Maintain a contingency fund for unforeseen expenses or market fluctuations
    • Develop alternative strategies for different market scenarios

Post Registration Operational Compliance Requirements

Post-registration operational compliance requirements for recycling businesses in Pakistan include:

1. Environmental Monitoring:
   • Conduct regular environmental monitoring as per EPA guidelines
   • Submit periodic environmental compliance reports
2. Waste Management:
   • Maintain proper waste segregation and storage practices
   • Keep accurate records of waste received, processed, and disposed
3. Occupational Health and Safety:
   • Conduct regular safety inspections and maintain safety records
   • Provide ongoing safety training to employees
4. Labor Law Compliance:
   • Ensure compliance with minimum wage, working hours, and leave regulations
   • Maintain up-to-date employee records and contracts
5. Tax Compliance:
   • File regular tax returns (income tax, sales tax, withholding tax)
   • Keep accurate financial records for tax purposes
6. Corporate Governance:
   • Hold regular board meetings and maintain minutes
   • File annual returns with SECP
7. License and Permit Renewals:
   • Renew all operational licenses and permits before expiry
   • Stay updated on changes in licensing requirements
8. Quality Control:
   • Implement and maintain quality control measures for recycled products
   • Conduct regular quality audits and maintain records
9. Equipment Maintenance:
   • Perform regular maintenance on recycling equipment
   • Keep maintenance logs and schedule preventive maintenance
10. Employee Training:
    • Provide ongoing training to employees on new processes and technologies
    • Maintain training records for compliance purposes
11. Community Engagement:
    • Maintain good relations with local communities
    • Address any community concerns promptly
12. Hazardous Material Handling:
    • Follow strict protocols for handling and storing hazardous materials
    • Conduct regular training on hazardous material management
13. Emergency Preparedness:
    • Maintain and regularly update emergency response plans
    • Conduct periodic emergency drills and maintain records
14. Reporting to Regulatory Bodies:
    • Submit required reports to EPA, SECP, FBR, and other relevant authorities
    • Ensure timely submission of all statutory reports
15. Continuous Improvement:
    • Regularly review and update operational processes for efficiency and compliance
    • Stay informed about industry best practices and regulatory changes

FAQs

1. What permits are required for recycling operations?

Recycling operations in Pakistan require several permits, including:

• Environmental Protection Order (EPO) from the provincial Environmental Protection Agency
• Solid Waste Management License from the provincial Solid Waste Management Board
• Hazardous Substance License (if applicable)
• Air Emission Permit (if the process involves air pollutants)
• Wastewater Discharge Permit (if applicable)
• Transportation Permit for waste collection vehicles
• Storage Permit for recyclable materials and processed products
• Local government permits as required by municipal authorities

2. How much initial capital is needed?

The initial capital required for a recycling business in Pakistan varies depending on the scale and type of operations. Generally, a small to medium-sized recycling facility may require:

• PKR 5-10 million for basic equipment and machinery
• PKR 2-5 million for facility setup and infrastructure
• PKR 1-2 million for licenses, permits, and initial compliance costs